| |
The
colposcope provides an optical method for examining the illuminated
cervix and lower genital trac at a magnification intermediate between
the naked eye and lower power of the microscope. The colposcope as a
bridge between the bedside clinician and his colleagues in the
laboratory is appealing to both parties who see in it a mechanism for
the better understanding of the physiology and pathology of the organ.
Three levels of expertise: (i) The ability to recognize the lesion,
which in his opinion takes 3 to 4 months of training. (ii) The ability
to sample by directed biopsy the most advanced area of the lesion which
requires a year of training. (iii) The ability to predict
histopathology from the colposcopic pattern, a skill which may take
several years.
Morphological basis of colposcopy
Natural history of the cervical epithelia
The essential target of
colposcopic examination is the lining layer of the vagina, cervix and
lower endocervical canal. The most conspicuous item of the lining is of
course its epithelial covering and in the region under notice there are
three epithelial types to be found, original squamous, original
columnar, and metaplastic squamous, a derivative of the columnar.
The original epithelia
The embryological basis of
the original epithelia is provided by the lining layers of the
mullerian duct and of the urogenital sinus. Original stratified
squamous epithelium develops from the sinus epithelium, whereas a
mucus?secreting columnar epithelium develops from the mullerian duct.
Metqplastic epithelium
Almost all cervices show
evidence of transformation of columnar epithelium to squamous; at some
stage of their life history. The transformation is known as metaplasia
to the histologists and the area involved is appropriately known as the
transformation zone (TZ) to the colposcopist. The transformation zone
is the most conspicuous structure seen on colposcopic examinat ion.
Topogr
The limits of the
transformation zone are thus capable of precise definition. The caudal
limit is the site of the original squamocolumnar junction and the
cephalic limit, the junction between the metaplastic transformed and
columnar epithelia, the new squamocolumnar junction. When this band of
new epithelium is seen in its entirety, that is with columnar
epithelium on its cranial end, the colposcopic examination is termed
satisfacto to distinguish it from a condition where columnar epithelium
is not seen cranially and the new metaplastic squamous epithelium
extends out of sight into the canal. In the latter case the colposcopic
examination is termed unsatisfactory
Dynamic aspects and maturity
The metaplastic process may
span all epochs from intrauterine to senescence. It is especially
active prior to birth, at the menarche and during and after the first
pregnancy.
Typical or atypical metaplasia
Atypical metaplasia occurs
in place of physiological metaplasia & insidiously the typical
transformation zone becomes the atypical transformation zone. The
atypical process behaves in corresponding fashion to the physiological
process in that it seems capable of varying degrees of progression
towards an end point, frank invasive cancer, with varying periods of
arrest at intermediate stages, cervical intraepithehial neoplasia (CIN)
of various grades.
Basis of colposcopic appearances
The colposcopic image hinges
on three basic characteristics, the olm of the epithelium, the surface
conto of the epithelium and the arrangements of the terminal vascular
bed, the angioarchitecture.
The occlusion of the bright
red aspect of the cervical stroma by the development of a multilayered
epithelium is evidently responsible for the pallor of immature
metaplastic epithelium. With increasing maturity and associated
differentiation the physiologic metaplastic epithelium becomes less
pale.
If on the other hand the
epithelium becomes less rather than more differentiated it becomes
whiter after its contact with acetic acid. This whiteness, evidently
due to increased nuclear and cellular density combined with an
increased meshwork of keratin filaments, is marked where metaplasia has
become atypical and acetowhite epithelium is a feature, although not
pathognomonic, of this atypical change.
Often in acetowhite
epithelium, intraepithelial vessels are absent. In this case the
opacity of the nucleardense epithelium prevents the observer from
seeing subepithelial vessels, so that the epithelium is seen as white.
Sometimes intraepithelial vascular arrangements are sufficiently
characteristic as to warrant names for some atypical appearances. Thus
when the capillaries are studded through the epithelium and seen end on
as red points, the term punctation is used. Equally common is a system
of capillaries in a wall?like structure which subdivides blocks of
tissues, honeycomb fashion, the so?called mosaic. Combinations of these
appearances occur. Uncommonly there is an exaggeration of the vascular
pattern such that vessels appear on or near the surface of the
epithelium. These horizontal vessels show bizarre variations of caliber
and of branching and are termed atypical vessels. These striking
vessels are usually indicative of invasion. The tumor angiogenic factor
seems to play an important part in this new vessel formation. At times
white patches can be seen with the unaided eye which are termed
leukoplakia. These are due to a thick keratin covering which may
overlie both histologically normal and atypical epithelium. When the
atypical growth process is sufficiently exuberant surface
irregularities appear, culminating in conspicuous ridging and folding,
the so?called microexaphydia or mountain?range appearance of invasive
cancer.
Effects of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection
Increasing recognition of
the incidence of HPV and the colposcopic disorders it causes makes it
necessary to include a new section in colposcopic morphology. In
topographic terms viral infection does not respect limits imposed by
the transformation zone and may occur within the original squamous
epithelium. Neoplastic potential is most often confined to lesions
within the transformation zone. In structural terms the key colposcopic
features are expressed in keratin and blood vessel distribution. The
former is manifest as variation of the whiteness of the epithelium from
low grades of acetowhite, often with reflective shine, to very high
grades such as to produce a thick keratin pile on the surface. Such
exuberance of keratin synthesis, with different effects on the stromal
papillae, results in characteristic surface changes from the
subclinical micropapilliferous and microconvoluted (brain?like)
configurations up to the exophytic of the clinical condyloma. The blood
vessel alterations induced by the virus can be conspicuous. There may
be no true demarcation between wart?characteristic vessels and those of
obvious precancerous lesions.
Recording of colposcopic
findings. The format adopted tends to vary with the individual or
individual institutions. The report is best made in writing, sketching
the cervix on a diagram.
Classification - The International colposcopic terminology
A. Normal colposcopic findings - Original squamous epithelium, Columnar epithelium, Normal
transformation zone .
B. Abnormal colposcopicfindings
1. Within the transformation zone
Acetowhjte epithelium - Flat, Micropapillary or microconvoluted
Punctation, Mosaic, Leukoplakia, Iodine negative, Atypical vessels
2. Outside the transformation zone, e.g. ectocervix, vagina
Acetowhite epithelium - Flat, Micropapillary or microconvoluted
Punctation, Mosaic, Leukoplakia, Iodine negative, Atypical vessels C.
Colposcopically suspect invasive carcinoma D. Unsatisfactory colposcopy
Squarnocolumnar junction not visible, Severe inflammation or severe
atrophy, Cervix not visible E. Miscellaneous findings Nonacetowhite
micropapillary surface, Exophytic condyloma, Inflammation Atrophy,
Ulcer, Others Indicate minor or major change Minor changes ? Acetowhite
epithelium, Fine mosaic, Fine punctation, Thin leukoplakia Major
changes ? Dense acetowhite epithelium, Coarse mosaic, Coarse
punctation, Thick leukoplakia Atypical vessels, Erosion (Ratified by
the International Federation of Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy, in
1990, Rome, Italy.)
Colposcopic Appearances
Original squamous epithelium
This epithelium is of
uniform pink color and contrasts with the red of columnar epithelium.
In the postmenopausal era the epithelium becomes paler. Its surface is
smooth and its vascular patterns inconspicuous as looped capillaries or
a fine network.
Columnar epithelium
The color is dark red since
each single cell column produces a lens?Re view of the underlying
stromal blood vessels. These finger?like processes contain one or more
capillary loops and are often vested with tenacious mucus. The thinness
of the epithelium and vascularity leads to ease of contact bleeding.
Typical transformation zone
The villous configuration of
the preexisting columnar epithelium is gradually lost until the surface
becomes flat. The pallor of this immature epithelium contrasts with the
red color of the previous columnar epithelium. In the well developed
transformation zone the epithelium becomes thicker and loses its pallor
as it matures.
Atypical colposcopic appearances
Preneoplastic lesions
tend to be confined to the transformation zone. In contrast SPI is not
so characteristically limited and may transgress the original
squamocolumnar junction onto the original squamous epithelium of the
cervix and sometimes extend further caudally to involve vagina. SPI can
also transgress cranially to produce lesions within columnar
epithelium. In other patients precisely defined asymmetric, map?like
areas of acetowhitening are seen within the original squamous
epithelium.
Acetowhite epithelium The
basic feature of the atypical transformation zone is ephemeral white or
white?gray, clear cut areas with or without an obvious keratin covering
and with or without conspicuous alterations of the capillary bed. This
appearance persists for several minutes. The rate of color change may
be slow especially with the shiny reflective change seen in many minor
lesions (e.g. SPI). There is a general correspondence between the
degrees of whiteness and the grade of the histological abnormality. The
less shiny and the more opaque the lesion the more likely is there to
be significant CIN.
Leukoplakia (keratosis).
White keratotic elevations, extensive or patchy, apparent to the naked
eye are termed leukoplakia to distinguish them from acetowhite
epithelium. Leukoplakia within the transformation zone may reflect
either benign HPV infection or CIN. Leukoplakia is also seen in
original squamous epithelium where it has no clinical significance or
is due to HPV infection.
Punctation. This term is
applied to the presence of a fine stippling within the epithelium
produced by the end?on view of intraepithelial capillaries closely
spaced with grid?like patterns. In more pronounced punctation there is
an increase in caliber and spacing and in most pronounced exarnples
there is even greater dilatation and spacing with irregular intervals.
Mosaic. Here fine vessels
form lines or partitions between blocks of acetowhite epithelium often
regular in size and shape. More extensive grades show increasing
irregularity in the epithelial blocks marked out by septa with coarser
more conspicuous vessels and an overall increase in intercapillary
distance.
Vessels with warty
characteristics. Vessels with warty characteristics may be disposed
vertical or horizontal to the plane of the epithelium. The former
resemble hairpin capillary loops of uniform vessel caliber and have a
punctate?like appearance. The latter produce ill?defined mosaic?like
patterns, with less complete boundaries than true mosaic.
Atypical vessels. An
exaggeration of the vascular abnormalities may occur as the lesion
becomes more severe in type. They demonstrate gross variation in
caliber and course with bizarre irregular branching grading into the
specific appearances of the vessels of frank cancer.
Surface configuration
changes. The colposcope may reveal micropapill projections (the
so?called asperities) occurring in acetowhite areas of the
transformation zone and within HPV?infected areas outside the
transformation zone. Sometimes the accent is on microconvolutions much
broader than the micropapillary structures. These brain?like epithelial
derangements usually contain a variety of mosaictype vascular
arrangement. A further striking and most significant alteration takes
the form of microexop Such small protuberances or excresences may
herald the onset of or indicate early invasive disease. Grading of
atypical (abnormal) colposcopic appearances
Grade I (inignficant. not
suspicious . Acetowhite epithelium, usually shiny or semitransparent,
borders not necessarily sharp, with or without fine?caliber vessels,
often with ill?defined patterns; absence of atypical vessels; small
intercapillary distance.
Grade II (sigaidcant.
suspicious . Acetowhite epithelium of greater opacity with sharp
borders; with or without dilated caliber, regularly shaped vessels;
defined patterns; absence of atypical vessels; usually increased
intercapillary distance.
Grade HI (highly
significant, highly suspicious . Very white or gray opaque epithelium;
sharply bordered; dilated caliber, irregularly shaped, often coiled,
occasionally atypical vessels; increased but variable intercapillary
distance; and sometimes irregular surface contour ?microexophytic
epithelium.
In Grade I appearances the
histologic appearances overlap from metaplastic epithelium (both
immature and mature, the so?called abnormal or acanthotic epithelium)
to SPI and CIN 1. In Grade 11, the findings are more prone to be CIN
2?3 while in Grade 111, CIN 3 or early invasion can be expected. The
latter diagnosis is probable in the presence of atypical vessels and
microexophytia.
A new and less subjective
approach to the problem of predicting histologic diagnosis in the
presence of HPV, especially with the minor lesions, is a scoring system
constructed by Reid and colleagues in 1984 and modified in 1985. Four
colposcopic signs, margin (including surface contour and topography),
color,vessels and iodine res " ponse are graded into three objective
categories. In general the more wart?like the lesion the lower the
score. Combining these four individual signs the colposcopic index was
97% correct in forecasting either SPI or lower grade dysplasia, or CIN
3.
Atypical colposcopic
appearances of doubtful or physiological significance Colposcapically
suspect overt carcinoma Overt cancer may be colposcopically recognized
in the absence of its classical signs by the better lighting and
magnification afforded by the colposcope. This entity, known as the
colposcopically suspect overt carcinoma, whilst rare, is obvious after
acetic acid application, with its striking raised edge, irregular
surface contour, the so?called 'mountain range' appearance, and even
more striking bizarre blood vessels which show marked alterations in
shape, size, caliber, direction and arrangement.
Overt carcinoma
All features described
in the previous entity become exaggerated when clinically recognized
invasive cancer is present. The surface contour is irregular with
nodulation and ulceration. Thin?walled bizarre blood vessels show
sudden variation in caliber, often with gross dilatation, and are
frequently unbranched for long courses. Contact bleeding is frequent.
Adenocarcinoma and adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS)
The colposcopic appearances
of invasive squamous cell carcinoma and invasive adenocarcinoma may be
similar although subtle differences are usually evident. In the latter
villous surface configurations may resemble normal columnar epithelium
but there is usually gross distortion, fusion and bridging of the villi
and presence of atypical vessels. In AIS, villous outgrowths are
present which closely mimic the surface configuration of normal
columnar epithelium. The distinguishing feature of the villi, which are
often fas_td, after the application of acetic acid is their striking
white col . AIS lesions are frequently within view of the colposcope,
may be multifocal and often coexist with CIN.
Miscellaneous colposcopic appearances
Condyloina. These exophytic
structures may be present both in the cervical transformation zone and
original squamous epithelium. Accompanying lesions of similar
morphology are often found on the vagina and vulva.
Vaginocervicifis.
Inflammatory lesions are characterized by prominent alterations in the
epithelial capillaries which are coiled, dilated and sometimes
duplicated. They may occur in punctate-like or mosaic-like patterns not
unlike those present in intraepithelial neoplasia. Differentiation of
the two conditions which is facilitated with increasing experience is
usually possible. Such appearances, typical of Trichomonas and
Neisserian infections, are often of such intensity as to render
discernment of an associated serious lesion difficult.
Ulcers. These can arise from
trauma, chemical agents or from microbial origin such as herpes
genitalis, syphilitic and tuberculous infection.
True erosion. Of importance
in the interpretation of significance of true erosion is the epithelium
at the edge. Most often the edge of such lesions is of normal
appearance. If one sees an edge beset with acetowhite epithelium,
punctation and so forth, the lesion probably represents loss of the
fragile epithelium of intraepithelial neoplasia.
Atrophic cervicifis
(estrogen deficient cervicids). The atrophic epithelium is predictably
thin and fragile and upon instrumentation is prone to bleed in the form
of petechiae. These changes are usually reversed by estrogen therapy.
Post-irradiation change The
white appearance of the irradiated cervix is beset with
bizarre?appearing blood vessels assuming unusual patterns, which may be
difficult to differentiate from the atypical vessels of malignant
disease.
Polyps. Polyps can assume
appearances characteristic of either columnar epithelium, typical and
atypical transformation zone or their combinations.
PLACE OF COLPOSCOPY
Aids localization of the lesion
CIN lesions almost always
occur within the transformation zone which is usually visible in its
entirety with or without the use of the cervical speculum. Six states
are possible in colposcopic assessment of an abnormal smear report: (i)
The lesion is focal and can be seen in its entirety. (ii) The lesion's
upper limit is not seen as it disappears into the canal. Such
unsatisfactory colposcopic examinations are significantly increased in
women aged over 40 years and may exceed 50% of examinations in the
postmenopausal woman. (air) The lesion may extend to the vagina. (iv)
No lesion is visible. (v) Adequate opinion is prejudiced in the
presence of severe acute inflammatory changes. (vi) Concurrent lesions
on vagina and/or vulva and/or anus are evident.
Aid in selection of biopsy type
In the absence of a
colposcopy service, biopsy is more rigorously proscribed; conization is
recommended. On the other hand, where colposcopy is used the type and
size of biopsy such as punch, cone or wedge is adapted to the lesion
with great precision. The cone biopsy rate falls sharply in favor of an
increase in the rate of the smaller colposcopically directed punch
biopsy. Some authorities supplement colposcopically directed biopsy
with the use of endocervical curettage. Alternatively the cervical
canal can be further evaluated by use of the endocervical brush
(cytobrush) ) technique.
Aid in management of abnormal smear in pregnancy
By reducing the incidence of
conization. Aid in selection of treatment for early invasive cancer
The recognition of the colposcopically overt carcinoma. Aid in selection of treatment for CIN and SPI
There tend to be less
hysterectomies, more therapeutic conizations and a distinct trend
towards local physical destruction of lesions.
Aid in identification and management of vaginal extension of intraepithelial neoplasia
The occasional presence of
the transformation zone on the vaginal wall may be followed by the
appearance of an intraepithelial lesion in this unusual site.
Aid in follow-up of women treated for early invasive carcinoma and intraepithelial neoplasia
In women treated by the
methods of physical destruction, colposcopy is obligatory in their
follow?up. After treatment of lesions by conization and hysterectomy,
colposcopy is indicated during the first year of the follow?up period
or thereafter in the event of an abnormality in the smear report.
Colposcopy is also mandatory for prospective follow?up of women with
SPI and/or CIN I being observed instead of treated. Spontaneous
regression has been noted colposcopically.
Reduction in unnecessary biopsy
Many clinicians still biopsy
red areas seen by the naked eye on the cervix despite the fact that
many such areas turn out to be columnar epithelium. A glance through
the colposcope usually shows the normality of such conditions and so
avoids unnecessary interference.
Aid in research
A less recognized role for
colposcopy is as an aid to clinical and basic research. Great strides
in the understanding of cervical carcinogenesis and indeed
carcinogenesis in general have been instigated in this way.
Ref. Coppleson M &
Pixley EC Colposcopy of Cervir. In Gynecologic Oncology. By Coppleson
M, et al. 2'd ad. Churchill Livingstone, New York 1992, pp. 297-323 |
|